I've owned both and at the same time, MSF is an ok game, but for me MSF left and BSD is a keeper.
MSF is a tough game, getting to the wizard mode is no easy feat, I really like the animations on the DMD and there is something to be said for the larger DMD. It really does add something, the sounds are amazing and a very goof fit for the theme. Problem with the game is from a scoring perspective it comes down to one thing. Shoot the right ramp, right ramp lights lock, and multiball is the most lucrative thing in the game. The multiball is quite unique in that it can be tough to start and isn't an automatic thing. The modes are all well done with a nice variety of shots, but end of the day the game just didn't hold my interest.
?BSD I love, it's fast it's hard, and mist multiball is a great unique feature. The sounds are great and it's just an a** kicker, and the tripple stacking is such a nice feeling. Shallow as hell, but what it does it does right. One of my favorite vidoe modes in pinball.
Like I said MSF isn't a bad game I just prefer BSD over it. Long term I don't think MSF makes a keeper game as it can get repetitive shooting the right ramp over and over again for multiball.
Hopefully this helps |